Let's Talk Seriously About Cake

For another post about Buttermilk White Cake, please click here:  Holli's Birthday: Lady John Deere Cake

Since my exclusive online agreement is up with The Dabbling Mum here is the reprint of the original "Seven Professional Secrets of Baking a Great Cake" with more photos added.

*********************

       

Seven Professional Secrets to Baking a Great Cake

I’m the daughter of a cake decorator so while my high school friends baby-sat for extra money, I baked.  With great pride I remember that many people from our small town wouldn’t celebrate a birthday without one of my mother’s cakes on their tables.  There was good reason for that.  Her seven simple secrets turn a good cake into a great cake.

1.  Add fruit or fruit sauce.

Long before it became popular to replace the oil in a cake mix with an equivalent amount of applesauce, we added fruit purees along with the oil to ours. The fruit adds moisture, creates depth to the flavors, and can turn the texture of eveb a boxed cake mix into the more homespun grainy texture of a scratch cake. The fruit puree should be in the same amount as the oil, usually 1/3 of a cup for a single batch mix, and reduce the liquid of the recipe by the same amount.

2. Line the bottom of the baking pan with waxed paper.

Using the bottom of the pan as a template, trace with a pencil and cut out.  Lay the paper in the pan after spraying with cooking spray.  The waxed paper keeps the cake layer from sticking when flipping it out of the pan and serves as a temporary base to set the cake on if making a torte or putting filling between the layers.  When cool slowly peel the wax paper off.

3. Monitor for consistent oven temperature.

One of the easiest ways to bake a great cake is to make sure the oven heats to the correct temperature and stays there.  To check oven temperature manually, bake a white cake at 350 degrees as most recipes direct.  It should rise steadily up the sides of the pan while maintaining an almost perfectly level top.  If the top crowns or domes, or if the cake browns before it’s done, the oven is probably baking at several degrees higher than what the setting says.  Thermometers that hook onto the racks inside the oven can be purchased from most kitchen stores and general retailers.  Check the oven temperature in an empty stove to know how to adjust the settings for future baking.

4.  Do not over bake.

“White cake is supposed to be white, not brown,” my mother always said. 

   

We dismissed all the normal rules for telling when a cake is done.  If you wait until the sides of the cake pull away from the pan, it’s over baked.   If you wait until a knife blade inserted in the center comes out completely clean, it’s over baked.  If the cake looks dry and dull matte colored out of the oven, it's over baked.

  We used the color test, followed by the pinch test.  When the cake had lost it’s wet look, and on a white or yellow cake when it just barely had started to golden, not brown, then we would open the oven and pinch a small dab of the “skin” off the top of the center.  If the pinch off the top was still gooey but you can see cake structure set up (it looks like a sponge) underneath it, it’s done.  Take it out.  Once it’s out of the oven, that very last 1/4th of an inch of gooey cake will go ahead and set from the heat coming up underneath it.

5.  Let it set for five minutes before you do anything else.

The rule is the same as letting a roast or a turkey stand for five minutes before carving it.  The juices will redistribute themselves to keep the meat juicier and easier to slice. 

The same is true of cakes.  Let it stand a few minutes to allow the internal structure to set before flipping it over onto any kind of serving plate.  This will keep it from cracking and allow the final heat to distribute and finish baking through.  At this point, the cake will pull away from the sides, making it easier to turn out of the pan.

6.  Crumb coat icing

This is a trick of professionals that is rarely used at home, but it only takes a few extra minutes and the end product is well worth the time.  Using your choice of frosting, even if it’s commercially made, take about a ½ cup of it and thin it down with water until it is the consistency of a glaze, almost too thin to put on with a knife.  When the cake has barely cooled, spread the crumb coat icing all over it.  It only takes enough to “seal” in the moisture and crumbs but isn’t supposed to cover any of the color.  Let this set for a half of an hour to dry before frosting the cake.  It can also serve as a base coat and will protect the cake overnight if the frosting needs to be applied much later. 

7. Refrigerate.

Although cakes taste best served at room temperature, they retain moistness best when kept cool and covered.

Recently, my husband and I went to a wedding and at the reception my husband took the first bite of our shared piece of cake and without swallowing it, looked at me in panic.  He reached down and scraped off the icing on our piece to reveal the browned side of the cake.  He swallowed his bite, folded his napkin over the cake to try to hide it, and whispered, “I don’t think this decorator knows that white cakes are supposed to be white.”  Mom would be so proud to know that her simple rules have at added up to big results...at least with my family.

 

Buttermilk White Cake

Recipe by Glenna Anderson Muse

Ingredients:

3 cups cake flour, sifted
1 tsp. baking powder
½ tsp. baking soda
¾ cup butter at room temperature
2 cups sugar
1 Tbsp. vanilla
4 egg whites
1/2 cup buttermilk
½ cup applesauce
1/3 cup oil

Directions:

1. In a bowl, mix together cake flour, baking powder, and baking soda. Set aside.
2. In a mixing bowl, combine butter and sugar until fluffy. 
3. Add rest of ingredients  (except flour mixture) and mix until creamed.
4. Gradually mix in flour mixture until all is combined.  Continue to beat, incorporating air, for an additional 1 minutes.
5. Pour in to 3 8” greased and wax paper lined rounds or 1  9”x13” pan.
Bake 20-25 minutes for the rounds, 30-35 minutes for 9”x13” pan.

Buttercream Frosting

Ingredients:

16 oz Butter at room temperature
1 Tbsp vanilla
7 cups powdered sugar (almost 2 lbs)
6 Tbsp milk

Directions:

1. Cream butter and 1 cup powdered sugar until light and fluffy.
2. Add vanilla.
3. Incorporate 1 cup powdered sugar and 1 Tbsp milk at a time beating thoroughly after each addition until all is combined.
4. Beat for an additional 3-5 minutes. The longer the frosting is beaten the creamier it will be.

To make crumb coat, mix ½ cup frosting with 1 Tbsp milk to thin.

Comments

[Rosie]

Hi Glenna,

What great tips! I have never really had the nerve to decorate cakes - just seemed a bit overwhelming to learn on my own...

Maybe I will find the courage to try now...

[sher]

I've learned so many useful things from you about baking cakes--things I never knew. The cake is beautiful!

[Glenna]

Rosie and Sher--Thanks so much for your comments. Baking is easy for me, I think, because I started doing it before I was old enough to know how annoying it is when it goes wrong.

[cookiecrumb]

My jaw dropped reading this post! I'm not a baker, but I learned so much! So very much. You are quite the pro. And quite the perfectionist (although I'll bet you have a drawerful of secrets for "repairs").
Thanks.

[Glenna]

Thanks for the compliment. Repairs, hee hee, someday I'll tell you the one about the wedding cake that after I set it up a big chunk just--plop!--fell off. Amazing what you can do with a bowl of frosting, a knife, and hot water.

[chanit]

Glenna your cake is beautiful!
I'm waiting to read all your Blog , later - Thank you !! ;)

[Glenna]

Chanit--Thank you! I love your blog too. I was just showing some of the pics to Gene (my husband) a little while ago and he was pointing out all of the things he wanted me to make from yours. I think I'm supposed to start with the plum or apricot cake.

[christina]

Wow, those are great tips! I just found your blog and will definitely be coming back.

[Glenna]

Christina--thank you so much for the compliment! See you around the figurative water cooler!

[Pamela]

I don't bake, I'm always in awe of those who do.

People often say in reference to baking that it is a science, well it's a science that I suck at and I'm a chemist, LOL.

Your site is wonderful and your cakes are beautiful!

[Rose]

Glenna, WOW!!!I tried the above recipe and turned my convection oven down, This is the best "white" cake I have baked! Mine kept coming out over done or not done in the middle. Thank you for sharing how to make and bake a fabulous white cake!

[Curly]

I followed this recipe two years ago from your old site and it didn't work. The instructions are not so precise and I end up making my wedding cake from Betty Crocker's Silver White Cake.

[Amy]

I saw this recipe first on 'The Dabbling Mum' then 'googled' you. I was very excited to find the recipe and gave it a go to practice for my daughters birthday. I just can't get the recipe to work though, it just seems that there is too much wet ingredient in it. A mouthful tastes nice but its just way to heavy. Do you have the right quantities listed? especially for baking powder which does not sound very much and apple sauce/oil which seems a lot. Plus your tips say oil and apple sauce should be equal but you give different quantities. many thanks for any help!

[Glenna]

Curly and Amy--I know it's been a while since you guys commented but I've used the recipe again a few times in the past year and I've yet to have a problem with it. The only thing I would do different now would be to add 1/8 tsp salt.

I did give two different qtys on the oil/applesauce but 1/3 cup each or as written will both work. I've done it both ways.

Thanks so much for your comments!

[Michelle]

Hi Glenna, I love this cake recipe, and I have used it for many cupcakes, wedding cakes, birthday cakes, etc! I have updated the recipe several times to change the flavors by adding instant pudding. I add vanilla for a yellow cake (I don't like egg yolks in yellow cake recipes) reduced pink champagne syrup for 1/2 the buttermilk for pink champagne cake, pistachio pudding for pistachio cake, lemon zest or lime zest for a lemon or lime cake. It works every single time, and I love it! When I add pudding I reduce the sugar by 1/4 cup. Anyway, thank you for this cake recipe, I love it!

[Glenna]

Thanks, Michelle! Love all of your ideas for adds-ins. Yum! That's one of the things I like about this cake--it's so easy to customize. Now I want cake.... :-)

[AmyK]

For the crumb coat icing do you use water or milk? Secret #6 says water and your instructions say milk. I am assuming it is milk but I am a beginner so I wanted to ask first :)
Also, I bought unsalted real butter for the butter in the recipe. I hope that is correct. I also bought vegetable oil for the oil. I hope that is correct too :)
I am still having a hard time finding the cake flour but the search is on!
Thank you for all the tips!

[Glenna]

Amy K--Actually either water or milk will work for crumb coat. I use which ever is handiest. Milk blends easier because of the fat in it. Vegetable oil and unsalted butter are great. The most common cake flour is made by Swan's and it's usually on the top shelf in the flour section in a red box... good luck!

[AmyK]

If you wanted a "normal" white cake, can you substitute the butter milk for regular milk, or do you use a different recipe?

[Glenna]

Amy--Yes, you can use regular milk and leave out the baking soda as well, which is a leavening that specificlaly works with the buttermilk. I'd up the baking powder to 2 tsps. Glenna

[Amy K]

I just wanted to say, "Thank you"! I made this cake for my mom's birthday and she loved it and it turned out beautiful and delicious!
Do you have any recommendations for other cake recipes, or a link to your recommended ones? Now I am inspired to try other flavors and designs :)

[Glenna]

Amy--Thanks so much for letting me know! I'm glad your Mom liked it too--that made my day! If you go to the home page of my blog and then to the categories on the left hand side, there's a category just for cakes. A couple of my favorites are banana cake and there's a clementine/olive oil cake that's sooooooooo good--and it's clementine season!

[Lindy]

I learned a lot from your tips and I have NEVER baked a cake from scratch before. One thing that puzzled me was your sugar instructions. In step 1 I combined all the dry items INCLUDING the sugar but then in step 2 you instruct to beat the butter and sugar(again?) ...was the sugar supposed to be in step 1? That was confusing. Thanks!